Doppelganger's Tango (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 5")

1

You Just Got Slapped (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9")

Boyz II Men

2

Marshall vs. the Machines (Journey to Farhampton) (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9")

Jason Segel

3

Night Night Little Marvin (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

Jason Segel

4

On the House (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

Cobie Smulders

5

Asking Out Lily, Pts. 1 & 2 (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

Jason Segel

6

Soul Bang (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9")

Sam Moore

7

P.S. I Love You (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

Robin Daggers

8

La Vie En Rose (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9")

Cristin Milioti

9

You're All Alone (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

John Swihart

10

And There She Was (From "How I Met Your Mother")

The Solids

11

Mmmm Mmmm Mmmm Mmmm (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9"/Hymym Version)

Wayne Brady

12

Barney Makes 3, Pts. 1 & 2 (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 9")

Francis Conroy

13

The Robin (From "How I Met Your Mother: Season 8")

John Swihart